"We would prefer brilliant innovators who are modest, considerate, politically inoffensive, and easy to supervise." I think that's probably true, but quite telling. 'Inoffensive' means they should think like us, agree with us, believe what we believe, have 'our' politics. I guess this is a piece written for those who think he's evil (and it does seem one of the Articles of Faith), and people who think differently are by definition outcasts. In particular, anyone who makes money, even if they invest it all in people, except for the huge amounts of tax they pay, are deeply suspect. I think he should be who he is, and we actually don't have to judge every action as being good or bad. We could just leave him be, and spend our time trying to be innovative ourselves, see how that works out?
We need him to make us a spacefaring species, once and for all. He's put us on that path now. The Moon, Mars, mining the solar system and defending our world(s) from space-borne disasters. He'll be remembered as the John Connor of humanity's move into the stars - he's the one who finally turned it around.
Well, there is also the fact that a lot of us don't agree with you about his supposed negatives. The very things that you cite as problems are positives to me. And what you call conspiracy theories I call truth.
Do people worry about the personality of the CEO of Volkswagen (let alone the original creator of the idea of a people's car)? I think reaction to Elon is more a means of expressing unity of support for some political ideas. The danger is when the noise becomes persecution and we lose out on elevation. Many lives have been saved by full self driving.
The problem is we've trained people through the media to abandon that very principle for select characters while overlooking it for others, without any provision for self reflection.
"His interventions in politics have alienated former admirers, including environmentalists who once championed Tesla. His management of X has angered advertisers and free-speech advocates alike. His involvement with the Department of Government Efficiency antagonized many, and government auditors questioned its claimed savings. He can be arrogant, impulsive, vindictive, juvenile, and spectacularly rude."
Overall your article frames issues with Musk as emotional reactions to his actions, rather than talking about the actual real-world impact of those decisions. Why exactly have his 'interventions in politics' alienated so many people? Why did his management of X anger free-speech advocates? Why did DOGE antagonize many? Your frame focuses on the emotional reactions and nothing to do with the substance. Were those emotional responses valid? What motivated them?
Are you afraid to mention his support for ultra-right-wing factions in European politics? Or the heavy-handed political curation of a giant media platform to suit his agenda? Or the wasteful spoilage of food deliveries and needless suffering and death caused by abruptly crippling USAID?
Instead you focus on the emotional responses in a vague way, as if all these emotional people might just be clutching their pearls at nothing.
Europe's "ultra right wing" is a pejorative for parties that would be considered right of center here in the U.S. Many of them support welfare programs the GOP would baulk at, so only the ignorant would invite uniform comparisons. Those outside of Europe (and many within) have little grasp of the cultural differences that render left/right comparisons between the U.S. and Europe pointless. The British Tory Party is moderate Democrat by American standards, for example.
As for Twitter/X - he owns it. At least, that's the response that was given when its previous owners were removing conservative commenters for arbitrary reasons, or caving to pressure from the heavy-handed political curation of the administration of the time.
Musk didn't stump for the Tories. He openly supports the AfD. Their state branches in Brandenburg, Saxony, Saxony-Anhalt and Thuringia are classified as confirmed right-wing extremist by their own country, not my judgment. Their national classification is tied up in court right now.
And then there's "Free Tommy Robinson." Nigel Farage, who leads the actual right-populist party in Britain, wouldn't touch Robinson. Musk then said Farage doesn't have what it takes to lead Reform. When the guy you're backing is too far right for Nigel Farage, the problem isn't American naivete about European politics.
On X, yeah he owns it. But when he bought it, he promised to end exactly the kind of politically motivated moderation you're talking about. If it was bad when the old owners did it, then it's bad when he does it, right? Or is it only bad when someone you don't like does it?
At least you're (badly) trying to defend the substance of his actions, rather than avoid them completely like the OP did, which was my entire point. If you want to have that discussion, we can, but you're not off to a good start.
Musk wouldn't stump for the Tories, because they're a left-wing part these days. It would be inconsistent for him to do so. And you're automatically presuming the AfD is some radical organization. They're right-of-center. Extremist is a matter of opinion, not verifiable fact by a specific, meaningful and agree-upon measure. Nothing in their agenda would be out of place for most right-wing groups the world over.
As for Farage, he's basically on his way out of UK politics, at the top level at least. He did what he intended to do; get the UK out of the EU. Musk is correct, Farage does not have what it takes to be a statesman long term. That's going to be someone else's task. That's a reflection of reality, not some obscure marker of fascism.
As for X, Musk purchased it to end the one-sidedness of the "moderation" occurring on the platform. I notice you didn't mention anything specific that he'd done wrong in that moderation. Most of the hard left who self-exiled either returned or have stayed on platforms such as BlueSky, which is not considered a mainstream platform.
We're still waiting on the actual evidence of fascism to emerge.
"And you're automatically presuming the AfD is some radical organization."
I'm not automatically presuming anything. It's almost as if you didn't actually read anything I wrote. By Germany's own standards in four states, AfD is officially designated 'extremist', and the status of AfD is currently being adjudicated at the national level. You ignored that I asserted I used my own personal judgment as the sole indicator. That's wrong and lazy.
You also seem to miss the point of invoking the "Free Tommy Robinson" episode. The point is not whether Farage makes a good statesman or whether he meets the criteria of fascism. The point is that Musk's views on Tommy Robinson were too extreme for Farage.
And for the hat trick, you didn't seem to understand the argument regarding X. You didn't deny he had engaged in the same behavior he supposedly dedicated himself to ending once he took over. But since you are apparently not aware of the multiple examples, here are some:
--Platformer reported that he had engineers boost his own posts by a factor of 1000 after his Super Bowl tweet underperformed Biden's.
--He suspended a batch of journalists who'd covered him critically, including reporters from the NYT and the Washington Post.
--Two days before Turkey's 2023 election, X restricted content at Erdogan's government's request.
--In India it blocked tweets about a BBC documentary critical of Modi.
I thought Musk was a big free-speech advocate. Is boosting his own personal tweets one-sided moderation or letting the market decide? Censoring a given foreign political opponent on request is also a weird free speech move, don't you think?
Is your argument that none of these is self-interested and one-sided, or that they are, but that's fine because he can do whatever he wants with the platform?
Musk's personality isn't the issue. Everyone had NO issue with Jobs' psychological issues - he was *loved* while being far, far more cruel to friends and employees.
Musk's issue is that he stopped voting the "correct" way. That was his real sin. Nothing he did justifies the hatred that's turned not just against him, but the innovations he's made possible that otherwise they'd be fawning over.
You don’t need to react emotionally, just look at the facts. EM is a racist, a fascist at heart, and it is unconscionable that the fate of Ukrainian people depends on his decisions.
If you're going to accuse him of such things, some independently-verified examples would be beneficial, not just one's own opinions presented as facts.
He'll be remembered long after the rest of us are gone. And with the objectivity of future generations, most of the accusations will drop away. There's far too much digital data for any future society to see him as a fascist.
"We would prefer brilliant innovators who are modest, considerate, politically inoffensive, and easy to supervise." I think that's probably true, but quite telling. 'Inoffensive' means they should think like us, agree with us, believe what we believe, have 'our' politics. I guess this is a piece written for those who think he's evil (and it does seem one of the Articles of Faith), and people who think differently are by definition outcasts. In particular, anyone who makes money, even if they invest it all in people, except for the huge amounts of tax they pay, are deeply suspect. I think he should be who he is, and we actually don't have to judge every action as being good or bad. We could just leave him be, and spend our time trying to be innovative ourselves, see how that works out?
We need him to make us a spacefaring species, once and for all. He's put us on that path now. The Moon, Mars, mining the solar system and defending our world(s) from space-borne disasters. He'll be remembered as the John Connor of humanity's move into the stars - he's the one who finally turned it around.
Well, there is also the fact that a lot of us don't agree with you about his supposed negatives. The very things that you cite as problems are positives to me. And what you call conspiracy theories I call truth.
Do people worry about the personality of the CEO of Volkswagen (let alone the original creator of the idea of a people's car)? I think reaction to Elon is more a means of expressing unity of support for some political ideas. The danger is when the noise becomes persecution and we lose out on elevation. Many lives have been saved by full self driving.
I'm impressed as hell by the talent he collects and orchestrates around himself to actually implement his visions .
Tupy's argument applies equally well to Trump (whether he likes that or not).
He's right about this: The way to evaluate people you don't like is by their accomplishments, not by your emotional reaction to them as a person.
The problem is we've trained people through the media to abandon that very principle for select characters while overlooking it for others, without any provision for self reflection.
It's Emmanuel Goldstein all the way down.
"His interventions in politics have alienated former admirers, including environmentalists who once championed Tesla. His management of X has angered advertisers and free-speech advocates alike. His involvement with the Department of Government Efficiency antagonized many, and government auditors questioned its claimed savings. He can be arrogant, impulsive, vindictive, juvenile, and spectacularly rude."
Overall your article frames issues with Musk as emotional reactions to his actions, rather than talking about the actual real-world impact of those decisions. Why exactly have his 'interventions in politics' alienated so many people? Why did his management of X anger free-speech advocates? Why did DOGE antagonize many? Your frame focuses on the emotional reactions and nothing to do with the substance. Were those emotional responses valid? What motivated them?
Are you afraid to mention his support for ultra-right-wing factions in European politics? Or the heavy-handed political curation of a giant media platform to suit his agenda? Or the wasteful spoilage of food deliveries and needless suffering and death caused by abruptly crippling USAID?
Instead you focus on the emotional responses in a vague way, as if all these emotional people might just be clutching their pearls at nothing.
Europe's "ultra right wing" is a pejorative for parties that would be considered right of center here in the U.S. Many of them support welfare programs the GOP would baulk at, so only the ignorant would invite uniform comparisons. Those outside of Europe (and many within) have little grasp of the cultural differences that render left/right comparisons between the U.S. and Europe pointless. The British Tory Party is moderate Democrat by American standards, for example.
As for Twitter/X - he owns it. At least, that's the response that was given when its previous owners were removing conservative commenters for arbitrary reasons, or caving to pressure from the heavy-handed political curation of the administration of the time.
Musk didn't stump for the Tories. He openly supports the AfD. Their state branches in Brandenburg, Saxony, Saxony-Anhalt and Thuringia are classified as confirmed right-wing extremist by their own country, not my judgment. Their national classification is tied up in court right now.
And then there's "Free Tommy Robinson." Nigel Farage, who leads the actual right-populist party in Britain, wouldn't touch Robinson. Musk then said Farage doesn't have what it takes to lead Reform. When the guy you're backing is too far right for Nigel Farage, the problem isn't American naivete about European politics.
On X, yeah he owns it. But when he bought it, he promised to end exactly the kind of politically motivated moderation you're talking about. If it was bad when the old owners did it, then it's bad when he does it, right? Or is it only bad when someone you don't like does it?
At least you're (badly) trying to defend the substance of his actions, rather than avoid them completely like the OP did, which was my entire point. If you want to have that discussion, we can, but you're not off to a good start.
Musk wouldn't stump for the Tories, because they're a left-wing part these days. It would be inconsistent for him to do so. And you're automatically presuming the AfD is some radical organization. They're right-of-center. Extremist is a matter of opinion, not verifiable fact by a specific, meaningful and agree-upon measure. Nothing in their agenda would be out of place for most right-wing groups the world over.
As for Farage, he's basically on his way out of UK politics, at the top level at least. He did what he intended to do; get the UK out of the EU. Musk is correct, Farage does not have what it takes to be a statesman long term. That's going to be someone else's task. That's a reflection of reality, not some obscure marker of fascism.
As for X, Musk purchased it to end the one-sidedness of the "moderation" occurring on the platform. I notice you didn't mention anything specific that he'd done wrong in that moderation. Most of the hard left who self-exiled either returned or have stayed on platforms such as BlueSky, which is not considered a mainstream platform.
We're still waiting on the actual evidence of fascism to emerge.
"And you're automatically presuming the AfD is some radical organization."
I'm not automatically presuming anything. It's almost as if you didn't actually read anything I wrote. By Germany's own standards in four states, AfD is officially designated 'extremist', and the status of AfD is currently being adjudicated at the national level. You ignored that I asserted I used my own personal judgment as the sole indicator. That's wrong and lazy.
You also seem to miss the point of invoking the "Free Tommy Robinson" episode. The point is not whether Farage makes a good statesman or whether he meets the criteria of fascism. The point is that Musk's views on Tommy Robinson were too extreme for Farage.
And for the hat trick, you didn't seem to understand the argument regarding X. You didn't deny he had engaged in the same behavior he supposedly dedicated himself to ending once he took over. But since you are apparently not aware of the multiple examples, here are some:
--Platformer reported that he had engineers boost his own posts by a factor of 1000 after his Super Bowl tweet underperformed Biden's.
--He suspended a batch of journalists who'd covered him critically, including reporters from the NYT and the Washington Post.
--Two days before Turkey's 2023 election, X restricted content at Erdogan's government's request.
--In India it blocked tweets about a BBC documentary critical of Modi.
I thought Musk was a big free-speech advocate. Is boosting his own personal tweets one-sided moderation or letting the market decide? Censoring a given foreign political opponent on request is also a weird free speech move, don't you think?
Is your argument that none of these is self-interested and one-sided, or that they are, but that's fine because he can do whatever he wants with the platform?
We demonize geniuses like Musk at our peril and risk limiting innovation. He was a hero when he supported the Democrats.
Musk's personality isn't the issue. Everyone had NO issue with Jobs' psychological issues - he was *loved* while being far, far more cruel to friends and employees.
Musk's issue is that he stopped voting the "correct" way. That was his real sin. Nothing he did justifies the hatred that's turned not just against him, but the innovations he's made possible that otherwise they'd be fawning over.
Some people just cannot get past other people.
You don’t need to react emotionally, just look at the facts. EM is a racist, a fascist at heart, and it is unconscionable that the fate of Ukrainian people depends on his decisions.
Without the Starlink that he developed, they wouldn't have had a chance in the first place.
If you're going to accuse him of such things, some independently-verified examples would be beneficial, not just one's own opinions presented as facts.
He'll be remembered long after the rest of us are gone. And with the objectivity of future generations, most of the accusations will drop away. There's far too much digital data for any future society to see him as a fascist.